AyeTea

...IT in Tea Break Sized Bytes

  • Increase font size
  • Default font size
  • Decrease font size
Technorati Profile
Home A Room Without Windows Well Where Are WE

Well Where Are WE

E-mail Print PDF
User Rating: / 0
PoorBest 
Well a month has passed and I am still under a Linux Regime. 

The news from me is that I don't feel anywhere near finished with this project.  I think it is fair to say that I underestimated things somewhat on several counts:

  • I did not realise how engaging I would find moving over to a new operating system. On the surface Linux would appear to offer a similar experience to Windows.  However what I am learning is that things work pretty differently under the surface. From an intellectual point of view this has been fascinating to try and figure out.  I have though become quite transfixed with learning this new way of working. 
  • Getting things to work has been a lot more challenging than I had anticipated.  This is a downside to using Linux as I see it.  It's not that problems are insurmountable, but just that I seem to have spent a fair bit of time resolving issues that I know Windows does not suffer from.  Comments in the (apparently cumbersome, software wise) forum here have pointed out that I have been using some new hardware.  However I have thought long and hard about this and I can't say that this is much consolation.  Take for example the wireless N network card that I had to install fresh drivers for.  It may be the case that wireless N is new and standards are not officially ratified.  However on an identical machine with XP installation was automatic. 
  •  On a plus side Linux offers a very diverse level of applications, some of which offer something different from Windows offerings.  This has slowed me down somewhat.  When you have so much to pick from you sometimes wish for less choices!
  • On another plus side, The Linux method of using repositories is not only elegant, but makes installing software (well more mainstream applications anyway) very easy. I like this way of doing things, not only does it make it easy to try out different applications, security wise it makes sense as well.
  • On a negative side, quite a few applications are incomplete.  I think that this kind of is the flip side to open source software.  As it is supplied usually free, it is hard to complain about this.  But I think that Windows users would simply not be as tolerant about the software they download and use.  This is not to say that there is not plenty of excellent Linux software around.  One thing though is when you are looking for software to do a task it is sometimes difficult to separate the developed from the half finished.   
  • Another plus is that the quality of the distributions that I have tried has been superb.  At worst they have rivaled XP and at best far surpass Vista.  Not only that, there is a distribution for just about anyone, regardless of your hardware, intended use or visual preferences.  Over Windows the level of choice is exceptional although baffling at first
So there is good and bad to report so far.  I will give this at least another month before coming to any final conclusions.
Share Link:
Google Yahoo MyWeb Del.icio.us Digg Facebook Myspace Reddit Ma.gnolia Technorati Stumble Upon
 
Discuss (4 posts)
Re:Well Where Are WE
Jul 13 2009 11:22:19
Fir... just kidding.

Anyway, since my comments seem to be directly responded to in you post, I thought I'd comment.

1. I'm thrilled to hear that the move to a different OS has intrigued you. As I said in one of my other posts, I think the end result, not matter the OS you choose, will be that you look at security, thought processes, software style, etc in a different light. And that is always a good thing. I know th point of the trial was to look at things from a "layman's" perspective, but now your true colors have come to the surface, and are looking deeper. I just hope you are having fun doing it, and learning something new. Most of us linux geeks had to make the same transition, which is why we are so very supportive, and want to help people have the fun we have, not to mention the philosophical paradigm shift that can happen when you start understanding free/libre.

2. I wholeheartedly agree that is can be a challenge at first. Everyone who disagrees is a zealot who is not being honest with themselves. Wireless is one of the issues I think linux people are working as hard as they can on, and they have come a long way, but for really new hardware, it is not quite there yet. I think some changes are coming due to some red hat work going on. My comment was more that it was your desire to turn off G was some of the cause of the issues, but I think the end result was that you were able to do something within a couple of weeks of trying out a new os that most people never learn on windows (what, you've never compiled a program on Windows)? It's your computer, you should be able to do what you want. I'm just hoping that as more people use linux, more hardware gets supported "out of the box". As for the forum, it just needs to reload the window with the post values still set, and allow you to re-enter the verification code. The fact that it doesn't give you a second try is what kills me.

3. I heard the same thing from a non-geek friend recently about the apps for her android phone. It IS hard to find the best program without a little research. This is one of the nice things that is aided for new users by the add/remove menu in Ubuntu (and possibly other distros, but I can't speak to that). It at least gives you the top few programs, instead of the thousands in the repos, not to mention the gazillions of source code only versions out there. So, at least there are scales here. Now, to be fair, go search for a pdf printer program for windows. How many programs do you find? Which is the best? Which is SAFE?

4. See the last note about safety, and you hit the nail right on the head. Another valid point about the beauty of repos is software updates. On Windows, you hunt for updates program by program. On linux, most of them are updated from the update manager, which means the vast majority of the apps used are not just stable versions, but stable versions with bugs fixed and security updated.

5. Yeah, some software is better baked than others, you are absolutely correct (for example, if I had more free time I'd probably try to lean to program c++ so I could fix some bugs in pdf-edit). On the other hand, see the above example of the pdf printer for windows. There are hundreds of them, and most have a large number of bugs, leave things hanging around your comp on uninstall, and some may or may not have spyware. Most also cost around $20. So, Linux is not alone in the half-baked software department. And I know a number of people that complain about the $20 program they bought that has issues, but they continue to use it because they paid for it. At least with FOSS, you have a chance to fix bugs or move on to another program without losing more than time.

6. Yeah, I think the distros absolutely have some really nice features. On the other hand, I think I liked XP more than vista, unless you are talking eye candy. But you are correct - it can be daunting to find the right distro to use at first (and you have more than enough experience with this). That is why it is good to have people around to make suggestions you can learn from, and thankfully more and more people are getting to know friends who try out that subversive OS.

I'm happy to decided to extend, and I will definitely keep the rss bookmark and checkin on the forums. How are the other folks doing?
#141
Re:Well Where Are WE
Jul 14 2009 08:05:49
Hey that's great that you're finding it so fascinating. You've made a pretty good assessment of the landscape at the present. Who knows, with Google backing Linux now and working with hardware manufacturers, we might begin to get better hardware support.

But it's nearly always the case that a person installs Linux on a machine designed for a different OS so we shouldn't be too surprised. The only valid comparison is when you get a machine that shipped with Linux.

Let us know how the Audio guy is doing, last I recall he was having some problems.
#142
Re:Well Where Are WE
Jul 23 2009 08:20:23
Glad you too have become fascinated with Linux. One thing I've found is that, yes, things sometimes take more time, but what about all the time I used to spend on anti-virus/spyware scans, updating things, trying to get my HP AIO to work properly (months), defrag, and other maintenance? Now I have time to enjoy my system without using my credit card.
Looking forward to hearing more...
#149
Re:Well Where Are WE
Aug 31 2009 18:14:37
So, it has now been another month. Any updates from any of the pigs, or is everyone too busy playing with Windows 7 :^)
#155

Discuss this item on the forums. (4 posts)

JoomlaWatch Stats 1.2.8b_10-dev by Matej Koval Technorati Profile